An Educational Guide for Employers

Dear Employer,

In today’s workplace, employees are increasingly aware of their rights to engage in collective action—even without formal union representation. When workers approach management as a group to address workplace concerns, many employers are uncertain about their legal obligations and how to respond appropriately.

This educational letter explains your rights and responsibilities under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) when faced with non-union collective action, helping you navigate these situations legally and constructively.

What Is Protected Non-Union Collective Action?

The National Labor Relations Act protects employees’ rights to engage in “concerted activities” for “mutual aid or protection,” regardless of whether they belong to a union. This includes:

• Groups of employees raising concerns about wages, hours, or working conditions
• Workers collectively presenting workplace grievances to management
• Employees circulating petitions related to workplace issues
• Groups requesting meetings with management to discuss workplace improvements

These activities are legally protected under Section 7 of the NLRA, which applies to most private-sector employers, regardless of size or industry (with limited exceptions like agricultural workers, domestic workers, and particular supervisors).

Your Legal Obligations When Employees Present Collective Action

When employees approach you collectively about workplace concerns, you have specific legal obligations:

1. You Must Not Interfere, Restrain, or Coerce

Section 8(a)(1) of the NLRA prohibits employers from interfering with employees’ protected concerted activities. This means you cannot:

• Threaten employees with adverse consequences for engaging in collective action
• Interrogate employees about their collective activities
• Create an impression that you’re monitoring their protected activities
• Promise benefits to discourage collective action
• Discipline or terminate employees for engaging in protected activities

2. You Must Consider the Collective Request

While the NLRA does not require you to agree to employees’ demands, you must:

• Allow employees to present their collective concerns
• Listen to their concerns without dismissing them outright
• Consider their requests in good faith
• Avoid immediately redirecting to individual grievance procedures

3. You Cannot Insist on Individual Meetings

When employees choose to approach you as a group:

• You cannot refuse to meet with them collectively
• You cannot insist on meeting with employees individually instead
• You cannot condition the discussion on excluding employee representatives

4. You Must Avoid Retaliation

Any adverse action against employees who participate in protected concerted activity could be considered unlawful retaliation, including:

• Termination or discipline
• Schedule changes or reduced hours
• Reassignment to less desirable duties
• Increased scrutiny or monitoring
• Creating a hostile work environment

Best Practices for Responding to Non-Union Collective Action

When employees present collective concerns, consider these constructive approaches:

1. Listen Respectfully and Acknowledge

• Schedule a meeting promptly
• Allow employees to express their concerns fully
• Take notes to demonstrate you’re taking the matter seriously
• Thank employees for bringing concerns forward professionally

2. Ask Clarifying Questions

• Seek to understand specific issues and desired outcomes
• Request examples or additional information if needed
• Avoid questions that could be perceived as interrogation
• Focus on the substance of concerns rather than who organized the effort

3. Commit to a Response Timeline

• Inform employees when they can expect a response
• Honor the timeline you provide
• If you need more time, communicate this proactively
• Consider interim updates for complex issues requiring extended consideration

4. Respond Thoughtfully

• Address all concerns raised, even if you cannot accommodate them
• Explain your reasoning clearly and respectfully
• Where possible, offer alternatives or compromises
• Document your response and the rationale behind it

5. Follow Through on Commitments

• Implement agreed-upon changes according to the timeline discussed
• Provide updates on implementation progress
• Be open to follow-up discussions if implementation issues arise

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

1. Dismissing Collective Action as “Union Activity”

Non-union collective action is legally protected regardless of whether a union is involved. Characterizing such activity as “union organizing” or suggesting employees “don’t need a third party” could be considered interference with protected rights.

2. Immediate Remediation of Issues to “Make It Go Away”

While addressing legitimate workplace concerns is positive, making sudden improvements specifically to discourage continued collective action could be viewed as unlawful interference. Focus on sustainable solutions rather than quick fixes aimed at discouraging protected activity.

3. Soliciting Individual Grievances to Bypass Group Action

Creating new channels for individual complaints in direct response to collective action could be seen as an attempt to undermine group activity and may violate the NLRA.

4. Increasing Scrutiny of Participating Employees

Heightened monitoring, documentation, or performance management of employees involved in protected activities could constitute unlawful retaliation, even if framed as standard business practice.

When Employees Request Formal Bargaining

If non-union employees request formal bargaining over terms and conditions of employment:

1. Understand that without formal union representation, you are not legally obligated to engage in collective bargaining under the NLRA
2. However, you still cannot retaliate against employees for making such requests
3. Consider whether a good-faith discussion about workplace issues might resolve concerns without formal bargaining
4. If employees begin seeking formal union representation, additional legal obligations will apply

Conclusion

Responding appropriately to non-union collective action benefits both employers and employees. By understanding your legal obligations and adopting constructive approaches, you can address workplace concerns while maintaining positive employee relations and avoiding potential legal issues.

Remember that specific situations may present unique challenges. When in doubt, consult with legal counsel familiar with labor relations before taking action that could potentially violate employees’ protected rights.

Respectfully,

[Your Organization]

---

Disclaimer: This educational letter provides general information about labor law and is not legal advice. Specific situations may require consultation with a qualified labor attorney.